Disclaimer and Notice

THIS BLOG SITE IS INTENDED AND DESIGNED FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY, AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE EITHER LEGAL ADVICE OR THE FORMATION OF AN ATTORNEY-CLIENT RELATIONSHIP.

Showing posts with label ADR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ADR. Show all posts

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Mediating Workplace Bullying Claims


As I have previously written, bullying is a hot topic today.   Cleaning House and Cleaning Up Our Acts - Anti-Bullying Legislation, and Bullying Legislation, Revisited.  As such, it is natural for alternative dispute resolution (ADR) practitioners to move into this field.  However, caution should be used in doing so, and practitioners should consider in each case whether mediation is appropriate and, if so, what it should look like.

In the Fall 2011 issue of the ACR Conflict Resolution Quarterly, Vol. 29 No. 1, Moira Jenkins asks Is Mediation Suitable for Complaints of Workplace Bullying? Although she herself does not appear to come to any firm conclusions, the article raises a number of helpful points to be considered by managers and individual ADR practitioners consider the issue.  First, as Ms. Jenkins observes, bullying is often not well defined, and in the workplace bullying may be confused with a number of other activities that are similar but nonetheless distinct. 

Thursday, June 30, 2011

Bullying Legislation, Revisited.

I have previously written about bullying legislation with considerable suspicion. To summarize, "I'm not a fan." Specifically, I expressed the view that it's impractical, over-burdensome on business, concerns a fuzzy, subjective term that cannot be uniformly applied or understood, and reflects a policy conclusion is not empirically established at all, at this point, e.g., that forceful/aggressive employees are "bad" for business and meeker/milder employees are "good", and that we need to run one group out in favor of another.

Recently, however, I've explored the matter further with colleagues, through a question posed by Marc Brenman on ADR, Conflict Resolution and Mediation Exchange--"Bullying: Amenable to legislated approaches?"  Ultimately, although I appreciate that my view and understanding of workplace "bullying" has been broadened and enhanced considerably, I come to the same conclusion regarding the efficacy and desirability of anti-bullying legislation.

Thursday, March 31, 2011

CBA Arbitration Clauses & Other Statutory Rights

I do not know what the practice is in other jurisdictions, but collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) in the New Mexico public sector typically include a clause prohibiting all kinds of statutorily illegal discrimination, not just that related to collective bargaining.  In these same contracts, there are also mandatory grievance-arbitration requirements that purportedly apply to all provisions except those that are expressly exempted.  Moreover, although these contracts frequently state that claims for discrimination or retaliation based on union activity may be brought before the state labor board, the New Mexico Public Employee Labor Relations Board (PELRB), there is no such carve out or proviso concerning other statutory discrimination claims.
While a hearing examiner with the PELRB I had previously wondered, privately, if such clauses could be read together to require employees to assert these claims through arbitration.  I had, frankly, tended to assume such a thing could not be a good thing.   However, Hoyt N. Wheeler has written a provocative, pause-giving little article in the LERA publication, Perspectives on Work, Vol. 14*, Summer 2010/Winter 2011, about the possible positive outcomes such arbitration.  See “Unions and the Arbitration of Statutory Rights,” Perspectives at 26-28.